Peaches at Hershberger's (photo by Kristen Jones)
Food + Drink

Ohio Amish Country Food Guide

Whether you’re searching for cheese, produce or pies to take home or looking for a full meal of authentic fare, these locations are a good place to start.

Sept./Oct. 2020
BY Ohio Magazine Staff | Photo by Kristen Jones

Ashery Country Store
A family-run business for 50 years, Ashery Country Store sells bulk, locally grown produce and an array of deli cheeses and meats. 8922 St. Rte. 241, Fredericksburg 44627, 330/359-5615, asherycountrystore.com
 
Berlin Farmstead Restaurant
Dutchman Hospitality operates four spacious northeast Ohio locations, including restaurants in the heart of Berlin and Walnut Creek. 4757 Twp. Rd. 366, Berlin 44610, 330/893-4600, dhgroup.com

Boyd & Wurthmann Restaurant
A grocery store in the 1930s, this cozy eatery serves up homestyle breakfasts, lunches and dinners, as well as great pies. 4819 E. Main St., Berlin 44610, 330/893-4000, boydandwurthmann.com

Coblentz Chocolate Co.
This shop specializes in a variety of artisanal chocolates, including hand-rolled truffles, chocolate-covered pretzels and cherry cordials, to name just a few. 4917 St. Rte. 515, Walnut Creek 44687, 800/338-9341, coblentzchocolates.com

Der Bake Oven
This bakery and cafe is known for its freshly baked breads, homemade pies and apple fritters, but it also serves hearty breakfasts and great sandwiches. 4766 St. Rte. 39, Berlin 44610, 330/893-3365, derbakeoven.com
 
Der Dutchman Walnut Creek
Dutchman Hospitality operates four spacious northeast Ohio locations, including restaurants in the heart of Berlin and Walnut Creek. 4967 Walnut St., Walnut Creek 44687, 330/893-2981, dhgroup.com

Dutch Valley Restaurant & Bakery
Dutchman Hospitality operates four spacious northeast Ohio locations, including this Sugarcreek one next to the Ohio Star Theater, Dutch Valley Market, Dutch Valley Gifts and Carlisle Inn. 1343 Old Route 39, Sugarcreek 44681, 330/852-4627, dhgroup.com

End of the Commons General Store
Founded in 1840, this store once sold bulk items to the Amish community but now offers a variety of retro and gift items as well as Amish meats, cheese and traditional fry pies made fresh daily. 8719 St. Rte. 534, Mesopotamia 44439, 440/693-4295, endofthecommons.com

Guggisberg’s Chalet in the Valley
Since 1983, Chalet in the Valley has been serving Swiss and Austrian cuisine including house-made pierogies, locally sourced bratwurst with sauerkraut and the house specialty: schnitzel. 5060 St. Rte. 557, Millersburg 44654, 330/893-2550, chaletinthevalley.com

Guggisberg Cheese
The home of the Original Baby Swiss cheese sells its award-winning creations alongside smoked meats and more. 5060 St. Rte. 557, Millersburg 44654, 330/893-2500, babyswiss.com

Heini’s Cheese Chalet
Home of Bunker Hill Cheese, this landmark offers a variety of delicious made-on-site cheeses, as well as jams, jellies, meats and fudge. 6005 County Rd. 77, Millersburg 44654, 330/893-2131, heinis.com

Hershberger’s Farm & Bakery
The bakery is known for treats like fry pies and cinnamon rolls, Hershberger’s also sells fresh seasonal produce, canned goods and kettle corn. 5452 St. Rte. 557, Millersburg 44654, 330/674-6096
 
Kaufmann’s Country Bakery
One of the largest bakeries in Amish Country, this family business features breads, rolls, pies and cookies — all made from scratch. 4357 U.S. Rte. 62, Millersburg 44654, 330/893-2129, kauffmanscountrybakery.com

Lehman’s
This huge store focuses on nonelectric items and sells foods that range from jams and jellies to locally made honey, as well as manually powered kitchen tools. 4779 Kidron Rd., Kidron 44636, 800/438-5346, lehmans.com
 
Mary Yoder’s Amish Kitchen
This restaurant serves classic Amish favorites for breakfast, lunch and dinner. It also has an on-site bakery featuring a variety of homemade pies and cookies. 14743 N. State St., Middlefield 44062, 440/632-1939, maryyodersamishkitchen.com

Middlefield Original Cheese Co-op
This general store offers a variety of locally made cheeses, as well as jams, jellies, honey, maple syrup, ice cream, bulk foods and more. 16942 Kinsman Rd., Middlefield 44062, 440/632-5567

Miller’s Bakery
A short-but-worthwhile detour from the main route, you’ll find this small bakery with Amish-made breads, cheese tarts, apple fritters, doughnuts and more. Cash only. 4250 Twp. Hwy. 356, Millersburg 44654, 330/893-3002

Mrs. Yoder’s Kitchen
Gloria Yoder’s restaurant offers traditional Amish-style favorites including fried chicken and slow-cooked beef pot roast. 8101 St. Rte. 241, Mount Hope 44660, 330/674-0922, mrsyoderskitchen.com

Nauvoo Family Market
This market sells a variety of bulk food items as well as fresh doughnuts, pies and other baked goods. Try the sandwiches with locally made breads, meats and cheeses. 15979 Nauvoo Rd., Middlefield 44062, 440/632-5584, nauvoofamilymarket.com

Olde World Bakery and Bistro
This bakery and bistro with two Holmes County locations specializes in artisanal pastries and breads. Berlin: 4363 St. Rte. 39, Millersburg 44654, 330/893-1077; Millersburg (temporarily closed as of October 2020): 73 W. Jackson St., Millersburg 44654, 330/473-6008, oldeworldbakeryandbistro.com

Rebecca’s Bistro
The menu here changes frequently. Breakfast and lunch features fresh ingredients and gluten-free options. The tomato basil soup is a must try. 4986 Walnut St., Walnut Creek 44687, 330/893-2668, rebeccasbistro.com
 
Rothenbühler Cheese Chalet
This third-generation cheesemaker dates back to 1956 and offers a variety of Swiss cheese. Shoppers can also check out the display of traditional cheesemaking tools. 15815 Nauvoo Rd., Middlefield 44062, 440/632-5228, rothenbuhlercheesemakers.com

Swiss Village Bulk Foods
This large store stocks more than 6,000 products ranging from meats and cheeses to candies, mixes and other dry goods. 309 S. Broadway, Sugarcreek 44681, 330/852-2896, swissvillagebulkfoods.com

Troyer Market
Find bulk foods and fresh seasonal produce alongside a variety of jarred Amish Wedding Foods created with authentic recipes. 5201 County Rd. 77, Millersburg 44654, 330/893-3786, troyerscountrymarket.com

Troyer’s Genuine Trail Bologna
Produced for more than a century, this all-beef product is made with the original and secret family recipe. You can buy it at the on-site store or throughout the area. 6552 St. Rte. 515, Dundee 44624, troyerstrail.com

Walnut Creek Cheese
This market with two locations sells bulk foods, baked goods, meats, cheeses and canned items from Walnut Creek Foods. 2641 St. Rte. 39, Walnut Creek 44687, 330/852-2888; 4727 U.S. Rte. 62, Millersburg 44654, 330/893-3273; walnutcreekcheese.com

White House Chocolates
Most of the candy sold here is made on-site, in the store’s converted red barn. Favorites include chocolate turtles, nut clusters, truffles, toffee and more. 14607 Kinsman Rd., Middlefield 44062, 440/834-3133, whitehousechocolates.com

Go To: Cheese & Meat | Pastries & Pies | Jams & Jars

Related Articles

Woman looking at lamps at Lehman’s in Kidron (photo courtesy of Lehman’s)

5 Do-It-Yourself Destinations in Amish Country

The parts of our state that Ohio's Amish and Mennonite communities call home are infused with hard work and self-reliance. These destinations embody that do-it-yourself spirit. READ MORE >>
Pumpkin doughnut and coffee from Columbus’ Resch’s Bakery (photo courtesy of Resch’s Bakery)

10 Ohio Fall Foods and Brews

Take a flavorful trip through the season with Resch’s Bakery’s pumpkin doughnuts, Maggie’s Doughnuts’ apple fritters, great seasonal brews and food-filled Oktoberfest celebrations.  READ MORE >>
Kids petting goats at Hershberger’s Farm & Bakery in Millersburg (photo by Laura Watilo Blake)

Fun for Kids in Ohio’s Amish Country

Bring the little ones to Amish Country this season to stock up on adorable photos and great memories with the help of these destinations that promise to capture kids’ attention. READ MORE >>

See More Articles on:

Amish Country Ohio Eats