3 Amish Country Food Finds
Cottonwood Shanty shop owner and Millersburg native Alyssa Eliot shares some of her go-to spots.
Nestled in historic downtown Millersburg, Cottonwood Shanty is known for home decor. “The aesthetic is to create a mixture of European style that is natural and effortless,” says owner Alyssa Eliot. We asked the Millersburg native for some of her favorite food finds in the surrounding countryside.
Rebecca’s Bistro: This quaint bistro offers a menu of carefully curated eats. “I love getting Rebecca’s decadent stuffed French toast for breakfast,” says Eliot. “For lunch, I love their grilled cheese and famous chunky tomato soup.” 4986 Walnut St., Walnut Creek 44687, 330/893-2668, rebeccasbistro.com
Park Street Pizza: This shop embraces local ingredients and big flavors. “Their Creamy Chicken Bacon Ranchero pizza is heavenly with a creamy ranch base and zinging jalapeno peppers,” Eliot says. 215 Dover Rd. NW, Sugarcreek 44681, 330/852-2993, parkstreetpizza.com
Mrs. Yoders Kitchen: Gloria Yoder’s restaurant is a classic for a reason. “If you’re looking for an authentic, Amish-cooked meal, this is your place,” Eliot says. “And don’t forget to save room for pie.” 8101 St. Rte. 241, Mount Hope 44660, 330/674-0922, mrsyoderskitchen.com
Cottonwood Shanty is located at 65 W. Jackson St., Millersburg 44654; cottonwoodshanty.com
Local Favorites 2021: Night-Sky Photos | Appalachian Adventures | Birding Spots | Fishing Faves | Cincinnati Food Start-Ups | Dayton Desserts | Columbus Breakfast Spots | Columbus Kid-Friendly Finds | Ohio Apparel | Columbus Art Spots | Ohio Instagram Accounts
Related Articles
8 Great Shopping Spots in Amish Country
These retail shops across the countryside offer a mix of authentic Amish-made fare, modern clothing and unique gift ideas. READ MORE >>
Good Company Focuses on Comfort Food Favorites
Stop in for burgers, sandwiches or the signature 72-hour wings at this restaurant’s locations in Akron and Cleveland. READ MORE >>
.jpg?sfvrsn=395eb638_5&w=960&auto=compress%2cformat "Snowville Creamery whole milk buttermilk and waffle (photo courtesy of Snowville Creamery)")
Snowville Creamery Wins Award For Making a Better Buttermilk
The Pomeroy-based operation won a silver medal at the 2025 American Cheese Society Awards for the cultured whole milk buttermilk it brought to market in 2025. READ MORE >>