The Stubborn Brother Pizza Bar, Toledo

Yes, there is a family story behind The Stubborn Brother Pizza Bar’s unusual name.   

“My Dad wanted to open a neighborhood pizzeria, and his brothers did not want to,” explains Andrew Mancy, whose parents operate Toledo’s well-known Mancy Restaurant Group. “He went ahead and opened it himself anyway.”

In business since 2018, the Toledo pizza spot is known for its round, thin-crust pies that are made using filtered water that is molecularly modified to replicate that found in New York’s Catskills region. (The area supplies water to New York City, providing a key ingredient to its famous pies.) Flour for the restaurant’s pizzas is milled in Fostoria and the toppings are sourced from Tank’s Meats in Elmore, adding some local flavor.

--

This story was originally published in 2023 but was most recently checked that the location remains open in September 2026. Details mentioned in the article, such as staff, menu items or other aspects of the business, may have changed since it was first reported. Please check with the restaurant for the most up-to-date information before visiting.

--

Residents as well as students and faculty from the neighboring University of Toledo gather here to enjoy Old World pizzas, pasta, meatballs and more. Dessert options include soft-serve vanilla ice cream topped with extra virgin olive oil and sea salt.

Illuminated letters that spell out “Toledo,” retro games and a photo booth add to the fun atmosphere, as does the lineup of University of Toledo events on the televisions.

“We’re the number one supporter of UT events. You can catch Toledo soccer, football and events on the big screen,” says Mancy, who oversees the restaurant’s daily operations. “It’s a community built around pizza.” 

3115 W. Bancroft St., Toledo 43606, 419/720-1818, stubbornbrother.com