Cleveland’s Cloak & Dagger Gets Clever with Cocktails

Once upon a time, there was a very clever book-themed cocktail bar in Cleveland. Co-owner Casey Hughes describes the experience as the unraveling of a story, starting with a page-turner of a bar menu. The ornately illustrated booklet is equal parts thriller, allegory and mystery, teasing out cocktail descriptions that reveal the overarching theme.

“Every bar needs a niche, or it doesn’t stand out. I enjoy stories, cinema and film, and I started to think it could be a good theme for a bar,” Hughes says. “There are so many different kinds of books.”

Cloak — as the regulars refer to it — fully embodies its literary theme. Old books, vintage furniture and curious objects create the look and feel of a well-loved library. Considerable effort went into crafting an immersive environment that’s both intelligent and comfortable — a perfect foreshadowing of the gustatory exploration to come.

--

Editor’s Note: This story was published in 2021, but was most recently checked in December 2024 to ensure that the location is still open and the experience remains the same as it did then. The drink menu evolves each season, so cocktails discussed in this article were from the time we visited in 2021. Check the website to browse information about the current cocktail approach and lineup. 

--

“Everything is made from scratch,” Hughes says. “We do all of our own juices and syrups. Our staff developed all the recipes.”

Cocktails change thematically with the seasons — each menu book offers between 10 to 15 — and the bar’s masterful mixologists stray from convention any chance they get. (Select cocktails can be enjoyed to the fullest without alcohol, too.)

When we first visited in 2021, the autumn “Cursed” menu explored “cocktail oddities,” spanning unusual or surprising flavor profiles and combinations like the Pain & Sorrow, with popcorn and chile-infused tequila, a smoky elote mezcal, corn syrup and spicy bitters. The Death Roll imagined sushi as a beverage, featuring a house-made blended rum (with sesame, nori, sugar and salt), ginger agave and wasabi, garnished with a nori “fin.”

The winter season menu that year, “Krampus,”  was named for the menacing creature of German and Austrian folklore and featured cocktails that toe the line of mischief and merriment. One of Hughes’ own creations, Arose Such a Clatter, featured a pistachio and sugar cookie whiskey sour, which solidified her place on the nice list with us. 

In an unexpected plot twist, all of Cloak & Dagger’s drinks and carefully curated food selections are vegan. Vegans and omnivores alike will find the plant-based meat and cheese board a bold move. Heartier entrees include a “fried oyster” mushroom po’ boy and Buffalo-style Fresno chile pepper “chicken” skewers.

“We wanted to work with Chef Todd [Kronika] because of his creativity,” Hughes says. “It matches what we are doing with the bar.” 

Reservations are highly recommended. 2399 W. 11th St., Cleveland 44113, 216/795-5657, cloakanddaggercle.com

For more Ohio food-and-drink inspiration, sign up for our Ohio Magazine newsletters.

Ohio Magazine is available in a beautifully designed print issue that is published 7 times a year, along with Spring-Summer and Fall-Winter editions of LongWeekends magazine. Subscribe to Ohio Magazine and stay connected to beauty, adventure and fun across our state.